Homemade Baileys Redux

by Maggie Battista on December 22, 2010

in All Recipes, Desserts, Food Gifts, Holiday

Homemade Baileys

Ashley at Ice Milk Aprons encouraged me to submit a recipe to her Heirloom Recipe series. I’m so grateful she got me writing right now; it’s a super busy season but recounting stories from my youth makes me remember what the holidays are all about: family. I adore Ashley, and her gorgeous aprons. You can see her post here.

Hispanic and Italian American by birth, I was surrounded by so much amazing food growing up. We had sweet plantains and homemade refried beans every Sunday, and there was always a big pot of orange-tinted rice on the stove, loaded with so much chopped cilantro. Sure, we sprinkled Parmesan cheese on our plantains and served our beans with finger-thick slices of whole milk mozzarella, always finding a way to intertwine the foods of my Mom’s Honduras with my Dad’s Naples-infused Newark-New Jersey-upbringing.

The holidays were really no different from the every day, except that our dishes were just much bigger, brighter and even more exotic. We had tamales often, as they were one of those impressive Latin dishes that required extra time to prepare, something my hardworking family really only had around the holidays. And on many Christmas Eves, my Dad would make a rich, tangy “gravy,” filled with pork neck bones and so many cans of Italian tomatoes. I was in charge of opening each can, a task I took on gleefully, loving to watch my Dad on his rare appearances in the kitchen and knowing the sweet reward was a bit of the chef’s treat, a bite or two of that meltingly rich pork.

It wasn’t strange to incorporate other cultures into our festivities. Rarely would a family celebration conclude without a thick glass of store-bought Baileys, a warming Irish treat that my non-Irish family adopted as their own. My family closely identified with the Irish, always pointing out their centuries of suffrage. My Honduran uncle always said he never met an Irish man who didn’t intimately understand his own plight as a poor, hard-working immigrant who just wanted a good life for his family. Indeed, he never met an Irish man he didn’t instantly adore. (He also slyly requests his “Irish medicine” when he wants a tiny glass of whiskey or Baileys, whatever is on hand.)

Twenty years later, I met my Irish man. Born in Boston but raised to feel solidly attached to all his cousins, aunts and uncles in the old country, my husband completely understood me but didn’t quite understand my family’s infatuation with Baileys. From his visits to Ireland, he recalled how the coffee and whiskey infused cream was just something the old ladies drank instead of straight whiskey. It was rarely drunk in his family. In fact, he didn’t really remember tasting it until my Mom offered him a glass of the stuff with a few ice cubes. Now, he can’t get enough.

Homemade Baileys Recipe

When my sister’s colleague shared her recipe for homemade Baileys a few years ago, I laid my claim to the ingredient list and poured, measured and mixed everything until I found my favorite version. I also replaced many of the ingredients with the organic versions (although that’s not necessary) and homemade extracts (and that’s really not necessary but, I think, kind of special). I now make this each holiday season and bottle it in tiny medicine bottles. I love sending my holiday visitors home with one of my family’s favorite medicines to sip and savor once they’re home, out of the wintry cold. While this specific recipe hasn’t been in my family for generations, the spirit of it has and I’m so pleased to share it with you again, with some slight revisions from the first posting a year ago.

Homemade Baileys


  • 4 fresh hen eggs
  • 0.5 teaspoon of homemade almond extract
  • 1.5 teaspoons of homemade vanilla extract
  • 2 teaspoons of organic chocolate syrup
  • 2 teaspoons of organic instant coffee granules
  • 1 can of organic sweetened condensed milk
  • 1.25 cups of good Irish whiskey
  • 1 cup of heavy whipping cream

Blend all ingredients in a blender or a stand mixer with a whisk attachment. Or put everything in a jar with a tight fitting lid, and shake it all until combined. Store in the back of your refrigerator, where it’s the coldest. Shake again just before serving, and serve over a cube of ice. This recipe makes a quart that keeps for 4-6 weeks.

Ingredient notes: (1) I always use farm fresh eggs when I’m making something that isn’t cooked in some way. (2) Whiskey is a very personal decision so use whatever you like. I tend to use the good stuff like Basil Haden (my favorite) or Bushmills (my husband’s favorite). (3) Whiz this mixture up with some vanilla gelato or ice cream and ice in a blender and you will discover just how delicious a Baileys milkshake can be.

Homemade Baileys Milkshake

Maggie Battista

Founder at Eat Boutique
Maggie, is the founder of Eat Boutique. She started Eat Boutique as a blog in 2007, and sold out of her first gift box of small batch independent food in 2009. Maggie continues to offer unique and delicious handmade food in tasting subscriptions and seasonal gift boxes for food fans and home cooks. Maggie also hosts Eat Boutique Markets, where she spotlights cookbook authors and food makers. She’s written for Style Me Pretty, Food52, Time Out New York, Spencer Magazine, and writes a cocktail column for the popular wedding blog, Snippet & Ink. Maggie's also created retail experiences for the largest floral and event design company in New England. She regularly travels far distances to find the next great chef, farmer, food maker or host. You can follow her worldwide – and homemade – gastronomic adventures on Twitter at @mizmaggieb or @eatboutique. Maggie's first-ever cookbook Food Gift Love will be published by Houghton Mifflin Harcourt in October 2015. You may pre-order now.

  • Crishaskell

    wonderfully written, lovingly enjoyed.

  • Kristi Sullivan

    Hmmm… I may have to try this for my Irish husband and in-law family, and in honor of the amazing trip to Ireland I took this past September!

  • Kiersten P

    Thanks for sharing Maggie – definitely on my list of recipes to try VERY soon!

  • http://www.deliciousobsessions.com Jessica @ DeliciousObsessions

    Wow! I actually just had several cups (well, not actual CUPS) of Baily’s last night on New Year’s Eve. It was my drink of choice for the evening and I LOVE it! However, I had never stopped to think about making your own and this recipe sounds divine!!!! I’m going to have to give it a try!!!

  • http://www.aplumbyanyothername.blogspot.com/ A Plum By Any Other Name

    Thank you so much for sharing this special, special recipe! I was on a roll this holiday season making cranberry cordial and espresso liqueur as Christmas gifts this year. Unfortunately, the “extras” I had are now dwindling. And just in time your recipe shows up. I can’t wait to try it. From one Italian gal to another: thank you!

  • http://www.eatboutique.com Maggie

    Thanks so much, everyone! I’m so glad you all enjoyed this recipe. More liquid refreshment posts to come soon… :)

  • Pingback: Homemade Bailey’s : Rodeo Spoonful()

  • Pingback: Cordial Recipe: Honey and Saffron Liquor()

  • Pingback: The Official Site of Chef Georgia Pellegrini | Food, Travel, Lifestyle, Hunting and Redefining Slow Food » Blog Archive » “Corned Venison”()

Previous post:

Next post:

Copyright Eat Boutique 2014. Call us at +1-617-752-1105.

WordPress Admin